Race Has a Place in Human Genetics Research, Philosopher Argues

spencer news

Some scientists have argued that bringing race into the field of medical genetics research is problematic or even damaging. But Penn philosopher Quayshawn Spencer has a different view, one based on nuanced concepts of semantics and language, which says there is a racial classification that’s medically useful to reliably sample human genetic diversity. He published his work in the journal Philosophical Studies.

As an example, Spencer brings up a random sampling of the United States population to look for links between alleles and traits within the human genome. If racial distribution were irrelevant, he argues, the resulting proportion of Pacific Islanders from pulling such a sample—less than 1 percent—wouldn’t matter. But in actuality, Pacific Islanders have extensive genetic diversity so such a sample should really include about 20 percent of this group.

“There have been arguments that suggest it’s a mistake to think about race based on genetics in any way,” Spencer says. “What I show is that you can’t account for the meanings of some of the racial terms we use if you don’t think about some races as ancestry groups in the way that population genetics tells you they are.”

Full Story

Arts & Sciences News

Spencer Named Robert S. Blank Presidential Professor

Quayshawn Spencer, Associate Professor of Philosophy, has been named the Robert S. Blank Presidential Associate Professor of Philosophy.

View Article >
State Department Awards Penn Team $2 Million to Preserve Cultural Heritage in Northern Iraq

The two-phase, three-year project aims to revitalize the city of Mosul and its culture.

View Article >
The Nanotopography of an Atomic World

Physicists in the School of Arts and Sciences offer insights into the structure of atomically thin materials using nanoscale images of 2D membranes.

View Article >
Marking the Winter Solstice, from Neolithic Times to Today

In cultures the world over, the promise of longer days has provided reason to celebrate for millennia, according to Penn Arts and Sciences scholars.

View Article >
Electric Bond

Behind the discovery of a new class of electronic materials is a 20-year collaboration between two Penn Arts and Sciences physicists, winners of the 2019 Breakthrough Prize in Fundamental Physics.

View Article >
"A Home for the Holidays"

Center for Africana Studies Summer Institute for Pre-Freshmen alum Kyle Oden, C’20, and his family are featured in a CBS special celebrating families whose lives have been changed by adoptions.

View Article >